Condolence Message from the Holy Father


cardinal simon pimenta. 1

To my Venerable Brother
Cardinal Oswald Gracias
Archbishop of Bombay

Having learned with sadness of the death of Cardinal Simon Ignatius Pimenta, Archbishop Emeritus of Bombay, I offer heartfelt condolences to you and to all the clergy, religious and lay faithful of the Archdiocese. Recalling with gratitude Cardinal Pimenta’s long years of devoted service to the catholic community there and his many years of faithful assistance to the successor of Peter as a member of the College of Cardinals, I join you in praying that God our Merciful Father will grant him the reward of his labours and welcome his noble soul into the joy and peace of the Heavenly Kingdom. To Cardinal Pimenta’s relatives and all assembled for the Solemn Requiem Mass, I cordially impart my Apostolic Blessing as a pledge of consolation and strength in the Lord.

Franciscus PP.

– See more at:









St. John the Eva. Ch. Marol

1345678101112131415161718192020 21222324


Cardinal Pimenta laid to rest

Cardinal Oswald Gracias led the Mass.


Cardinal Simon Pimenta, retired archbishop of Mumbai, was laid to rest yesterday in his native parish of St John the Evangelist in Marol.

Despite the rain, nearly 5,000 mourners, led by archbishop Oswald Cardinal Gracias, paid respects to the priest who “lived his life” in the service of the faith.

“He was a true ambassador of the country who brought people of divergent views together. He was kind, gentle and understanding,” said Cardinal Gracias.

“Two days ago, I was in Hong Kong, where I spoke about his landmark role in church affairs. Thousands, including government officials and ministers, have beaten the weather to attend his last rites. This is an affirmation of his eminence,” he added.

Cardinal Simon Ignatius Pimenta died on Friday while he was resting at the Clergy Home in Bandstand, Bandra, having moved here as his apartment at the Archbishop’s House was undergoing repair.

From the Vatican, Pope Francis sent a “telegram of condolence” to Cardinal Gracias for the death of the archbishop emeritus.

He expressed his closeness to Cardinal Pimenta’s family and gave an “apostolic blessing as a pledge of consolation and strength in the Lord”.

On Tuesday noon, a special service was held at Colaba’s Holy Name Cathedral. Around 2,000 people waited to get a glimpse of Cardinal Pimenta, who served as the head of the church from 1988 through 1997.

The body was then transported to Marol for last rites. Priests at St John the Evangelist Church recalled the senior clergyman whose family continues to be associated with the parish.

“Cardinal Pimenta lived his life doing a lot of good work and uniting the Church. His two sisters oversaw the arrangements for the last rites,” said parish priest Fr. Clarence Fonseca.

Source: Times of India

Cardinal Simon Pimenta , St John The Evangelist ,Mumbai , Cardinal Oswald Gracias  
Altar at St. John the Evangelist Church, Marol.

Tribute to Cardinal Simon Pimenta; from SILENT VOICE.


Milestones in the Life of Simon Cardinal Pimenta


March 1, 1920

Born at Marol, Mumbai

December 21, 1949

Ordained Priest

June 1954

Appointed Secretary to Cardinal Valerian Gracias

August 1967

Appointed Rector of Holy Name Cathedral and Episcopal Vicar

February 1971

Appointed Rector of St. Pius x college, Goregaon

June 29, 1971

Ordained Bishop

September 21, 1978

Installed as Archbishop of Bombay(Succeeds Cardinal Gracias)

1982, 1984, 1986

Three Terms as President of CBCI

June 28, 1988

Created Cardinal by Pope John Paul ll in Rome

June 29, 1996

Episcopal Silver Jubilee

December 21, 1999

Sacerdotal Silver Jubilee

June 28, 2013

Silver Jubilee as Cardinal (Prince of the Church)


Source: Bernice Martin, niece of Cardinal Simon Pimenta; in The EXAMINER



Simon Pimenta


From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Coat of Arms of Cardinal Simon Ignatius Pimenta


Simon Ignatius Pimenta (1 March 1920 – 19 July 2013) was a Roman Catholic Cardinal and Archbishop Emeritus of Bombay (now Mumbai).


Styles of
Simon Pimenta
CoA Simon Ignatius Pimenta.svg
Reference style His Eminence
Spoken style Your Eminence
Informal style Cardinal
See Bombay (Emeritus)


Pimenta was ordained on 21 December 1949. Before coming to Rome to study at the Pontifical College of St. Peter the Apostle, he served as assistant parish priest in Bombay and worked with the Bombay Curia. In 1954, Pimenta graduated in Canon Law at the Pontifical Urban University. On 5 June 1971 Pope Paul VI appointed Pimenta as an Auxiliary Bishop of Bombay, giving him the titular see of Bocconia. He was chosen to become the next Archbishop of Bombay by Pope Paul and was thus appointed Coadjutor Archbishop of Bombay on 26 February 1977. On 11 September 1978 he succeeded Valerian Gracias as the Archbishop of Bombay. He has served as President of the Indian Episcopal Conference.


He was created Cardinal-Priest on 28 June 1988 by Pope John Paul II with the titular church of Santa Maria Regina Mundi a Torre Spaccata. He became Archbishop Emeritus of Bombay on 8 November 1996 with the appointment of Ivan Dias as his successor in that see. He died on 19 July 2013.[1][2]


Pope Francis condoles the death of Indian Cardinal Simon Pimenta


Vatican City, 20 July 2013: ‘Having learned with sadness of the death of Cardinal Simon Ignatius Pimenta, Archbishop Emeritus of Bombay, I offer heartfelt condolences to you and to all the clergy, religious and lay faithful of the Archdiocese’, wrote Pope Francis on Saturday in his condolence message sent to Cardinal Oswald Gracias, Archbishop of Bombay.
Cardinal Simon Ignatius Pimenta, who led the Indian Church during one of its critical periods, died in Bombay on Friday after a brief illness. He was 93.


‘Recalling with gratitude, Pope Francis said, Cardinal Pimenta’s long years of devoted service to the Catholic community there and his many years of faithful assistance to the Successor of Peter as a member of the College of Cardinals. I join you in praying that God our merciful Father will grant him the reward of his labours and welcome his noble soul into the joy and peace of the heavenly Kingdom’.
Pope Francis imparted his Apostolic blessing to Cardinal Pimenta’s relatives and all assembled for the Solemn Requiem Mass for the Cardinal.


A spokesperson of the Catholic church said the funeral details would be announced within a few days. Members of the Catholic community will pay their respects Saturday morning at the Clergy Home at Bandra.
The late cardinal headed the Indian Church as the president of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India (CBCI) in 1987 when Pope John Paul II allowed the country’s three ritual Churches to set up their own separate espiscopal conferences amid fears of tension, rivalries and acrimony. The cardinal was the archbishop of Bombay, the largest Catholic diocese in India, from 1978 to 1997.


Later when he was made the cardinal observers said the multi-faceted prelate earned the honor because of his ability to think critically and to be open to changes. The cardinal proved his leadership abilities in the Church by keeping his equilibrium when several contentious social and religious issues came to a head.


The Indian bishops endorsed their faith in his ability to guide the Church by electing him the CBCI president three times. During his six-year presidency, the Church weathered one of the severest tests of its unity — the inter-rite issue and the claim of the Oriental Churches to a separate identity.


After failure to achieve consensus on the matter at two successive CBCI meetings, the archbishop minced no words when he asked bishops “to rise above ourselves, our personal likes and dislikes, our differences, and chart a new and prosperous path for the Church in India.” The bishops at a plenary of the conference unanimously approved the new statutes of the CBCI, ending speculation about sharpening divisions among the rites.


Bombay´s second cardinal, Archbishop Pimenta was born at Marol in Bombay on March 1, 1920. He did his primary school studies in Marathi and passed the matriculation exam at St. Xavier´s High School in 1936. He graduated from St. Xavier´s College with a degree in arts. As a youth, Cardinal Pimenta was a voracious reader and a music and sports enthusiast. He played the violin and was skilled in cricket and hockey – which accounted for his frequent allusions in speeches to cricket and harmony.


After ecclesiastical studies at the diocesan seminary, he was ordained by the late Cardinal Valerian Gracias in 1949. Two years later, he joined the Urban University, Rome where he obtained a doctorate in canon law.


On his return to India, the young priest was appointed secretary at the archbishop´s house, and held posts of vice chancellor and defender of the bond in the matrimonial tribunal of the archdiocese. In 1960 he was appointed visiting professor of liturgy at St. Pius X College, the diocesan seminary, where he lectured for five years.


In 1967, he took charge as rector of the Cathedral of the Holy Name and was appointed episcopal vicar for the liturgy and for the pastoral formation of junior clergy. After a short rectorship at the diocesan seminary in 1971, he was nominated titular bishop of Bocconia and auxiliary to Cardinal Gracias. In 1977, he was named coadjutor archbishop of Bombay. On Cardinal Gracias´ death in 1978, he became archbishop.


He was a member of the Vatican Congregation for Religious and Secular Institutes, Secretariat for Promotion of Christian Unity and the Pontifical Commission for the Revision of Canon Law. The late cardinal´s balanced approach on controversial issues had been frequently quoted in religious and secular newspapers.


At a civic reception to the Indian bishops in 1988, Kerala Governor Ram Dular Sinha praised Christians for their contribution to the country´s development. Archbishop Pimenta, responded, asking the authorities to accept, not suspect, the Christian community. Governor Sinha had accused Christian missioners of fomenting trouble in Chhotanagpur region in eastern India when she was the federal home minister.


Cardinal Pimenta was quite vocal in 1992 when India went through sectarian violence that threatened the country’s secular credentials and existence as a single nation. The worst affected was Mumbai, India’s commercial capital.


He told an interreligious gathering in Mumbai that India had “deep psychic wounds” that needed healing. He was the member of the “Sarva Dharma Maitri Pratishtan” (trust for all faiths friendship) that organizes peace marches and interfaith meetings in Mumbai.


“More than physical, it is psychological and spiritual matters where spiritual leaders can singly and jointly help,” Cardinal Pimenta used to say at inter-religious meetings. He maintained that animosity between Hindus and Muslims, two major religions in India, needed political and spiritual solutions and urged the delinking politics from religion. He warned against destroying the country´s secular character through “mutual misuse of religion and politics to arouse passions.”


He also warned that a political party would become sectarian and exclusive if it aligned closely to a particular religion. He had also urged Hindus and Muslims to avoid irritants to ease interreligious tensions and urged both groups to reassess religious practices that do not affect the faith but irritate others. He said riots can easily be triggered by loud speakers, bells, drums and religious processions. “Such practices are not desirable and need to be looked into,” he used to say.
In his own diocese, the cardinal called for a diocesan synod and was very active in pastoral and charitable activities especially in managing 12 hospitals and 44 dispensaries, and has dedicated much to Catholic education.
Source: VR Sedoc & Mattersindia


Text from page
of the Vatican Radio website


Catholics mourn Cardinal Simon Pimenta


Bella Jaisinghani, TNN Jul 20, 2013, 12.25PM IST

MUMBAI: Cardinal Simon Pimenta, archbishop emeritus of Mumbai, passed away Friday night. He was 93.

A spokesperson of the Catholic church said the funeral details would be announced within a few days. Members of the Catholic community will pay their respects Saturday morning at the Clergy Home at Bandra.



The end came around 9pm at Clergy Home where the cardinal was recuperating from age-related ailments. Auxiliary bishop Fr Dominic Savio Fernandes said the cardinal was well all day.

“He had eaten his dinner and was resting when one of the nurses in the home found him slumped in his chair. A doctor was quickly summoned but the end had come by then,” he said.

Senior priests from the Archbishop’s House in Colaba had come to visit another clergyman who had suffered a heart attack and was admitted to Holy Family Hospital in Bandra. It was then that they heard of Cardinal Pimenta’s death and rushed to Clergy Home.

Cardinal Pimenta was born on March 1, 1920, in Marol village, Andheri, to Joseph Anthonyand Rosy Pimenta. He was an alumnus of St John the Evangelist School and St Xavier’s College. He was ordained priest on December 21, 1949. He retired as Cardinal at the age of 75 to make way for Ivan Dias.

“He was a nice, holy person who will be remembered for his giving, generous ways. He served as Cardinal from 1988 through 1987. He was an important leader not just in Mumbai but indeed India given that he was elected president of the Catholic Bishops Conference of India (CBCI) three times and visited Rome to attend various Synod meetings,” said Fr Savio.

The Mobai Gaothan Panchayat mourned the death of the man who made the East Indian community proud.

Archbishop emeritus of Bombay, Cardinal Simon Pimenta passes away at 93

Friday, Jul 19, 2013, 23:42 IST | Place: Mumbai | Agency: DNA

Created and proclaimed cardinal by John Paul II on June 28, 1988, he chose to retire in November 8, 1996.

Simon Pimenta

Simon Pimenta

Cardinal Simon Pimenta, archbishop emeritus of Bombay, passed away on Friday. He was 93.

The cardinal, who retired 16 years ago, was at the Clergy Home, the residence for aged priests in suburban Mumbai, when the end came, a church official said. The details of the last rites will be decided and announced on Sunday.

Born on March 1,1920 in Marol, in suburban Mumbai, Pimenta was ordained a priest on December 21, 1949. He obtained a doctorate in church law from the Pontifical Urban University in Rome in 1954, and after returning to Mumbai, he was given different responsibilities.

He was secretary to Cardinal Valerian Gracias, taught liturgy at the seminary and was in charge of the formation of young priests. He also published some works.

He was appointed titular Bishop of Bocconia and Auxiliary of Bombay in June 1971. Some years later, Pope Paul VI nominated him coadjutor archbishop of Bombay and on September 11, 1978 he became archbishop.

As archbishop, he called for a special conference of religious and lay people, he was  active in pastoral and charitable activities like managing hospitals and dispensaries, and dedicated much to Catholic education. He was president of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India for three consecutive terms until 1988.

Created and proclaimed cardinal by John Paul II on June 28, 1988, he chose to  retire in November 8, 1996.

Mumbai’s second cardinal emeritus Simon Pimenta passes away

HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times  Mumbai, July 20, 2013

Cardinal emeritus Simon Pimenta, the second cardinal of the Archdiocese of Bombay, passed away on Friday night at the age of 93 at the clergy home in Bandra.

The cardinal, who had presided over the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India (CBCI) for three terms, was appointed by Pope John Paul II as the cardinal in 1988 and went on to serve the diocese till 1996.

He passed away at 8.30pm on Friday. The clergy said that the cardinal was not suffering from any ailments at the time. “The news came as a shock to us. I used to meet the cardinal regularly at his Bandra home and met him last before my ordination as the Bishop in June,” said auxiliary bishop Savio Fernandes. “In fact, I was in Bandra yesterday to meet a priest who had a heart attack, and the priest told me after his recovery that the cardinal was doing fine and was happy.”

The cardinal, who hailed from Marol, was ordained as a priest of St Peter’s Church in Bandra in 1949 by the then bishop Valerian Gracias, who was the first cardinal of the archdiocese. Pimenta succeeded cardinal Gracias as the bishop in 1978 and then as the cardinal ten years later.

Inner view of the Cathedral

Inner view of the Cathedral (Photo credit: Wikipedia)









SION CHURCH “MONEY MAKES THE MARE GO”; is a proverb, we have heard umpteen times in our lives, particularly with Government administration, at various level. It is hurting to learn that this also applies to Church Administration, at Parish Level. However, in this particular case it has been happening at top of Hierarchy, in the Archdiocese of Bombay….What is worse; the sacred law is being violated to appease the rich and mighty….. Most of you, who are following SILENT VOICE, will be aware that this is the story of OUR LADY OF GOOD COUNSEL, SION. Parish Priest has permitted, Obligatory, Sunday Mass to be Celebrated at EVERARD NAGAR COLONY; inspite of opposition from other parishioners. Archbishop Cardinal Oswald Gracias has turned a deaf ear to representation and many letters, written by Parishioners. A Decree by Then Archbishop, Cardinal Simon Pimenta, too has been ignored by hierarchy, to appease the Rich and Mighty. SILENT VOICE has been highlighting this issue, for a long time….Click on the following links to understand, how the Hierarchy and Archbishop is PRISONER OF WHIMS AND FANCY OF  ARROGANT PARISH PRIEST. Attached video, narrates the tale of parishioners emotion, towards the Fr. Leslie D’cunah, who was transferred abruptly, for trying to stop this unethical practice of celebrating Obligatory Sunday Mass at Everard Nagar….


Dear Cardinal.

The parishioners of our lady of good counsel church Sion has been requesting you and pleading from last one year, but still the problem is remain same. Why is only Everard issues heard upon urgently ??? Is it because theyhave the financial muscle. The PPC members have come to you andexplained every letter and everything that has happened in parish. And now when PPC Members are changed after a rigged elections forwhich objection letters have been received by Fr. Richard and isforwarded to you and your Election commission for a revert. However people appointed are by Fr. Richard under a garb of fair elections. So it is not natural for the Everardian’s to say that the full churchis supporting them when 70% on the PPC are Evradians and Fr Richardsupporters.This is the say way Fr. Richard had taken permission 10 years back too. From the time Fr. Richard is come the church is divided not united. Ifyou remember I had asked you to give us new parish priest you saidwill look into this matter. And now it is stated that only Franklin is against the Everard mass.I am sorry to say that our Church will only hear to those who havemoney not the poor.


Dulcine Furtado Ex PPC VP OLGC

On Mon, Jun 10, 2013 at 12:17 PM, Sebastian Serrao <> wrote: >

Dear Franklin, > > It is the Archdiocese’s “British Minded” – “Divide & Rule” age old policy > which has brought the Sion Parish to the “Dogs”!!!. Why else would a > “laughing stock” Puppet Parish Priest would be brought to add “Fire to the > Fuel”. > > Since the Archdiocese lacks the will to solve these problems as it will > surely open up a Pandora’s box full of worms, the situation will continue to > be as it is. Slowly but Surely – “HELL it is”. > >

Regards >

Saby Serrao > >

On Sun, Jun 9, 2013 at 9:44 PM, Franklin Pereira > <> wrote: >> >> >> >> ———- Forwarded message ———- >> From: Franklin Pereira <> >> Date: Sun, Jun 9, 2013 at 9:42 PM >> Subject: Parish priest responsible for the the everard nagar mess >> To: Archbishop Bombay <> >> >> >>

Dear cardinal , >>

Today after the 9 am mass i met one of our ex parishoner who is now >> settled in canada and is come down for some personal  work while he was >> enquiring about the parish i told him about the everard nagar mass issue he >> immidiately told me that he was one of the ppc member during that time and i >> was shocked to know the facts and the trurh he told me how the everardians >> had put so much pressure on Fr. blaise lobo who was the parish priest how >> they had gone with a morcha to bishops house as Fr blaise had requested them >> to stop the saturday mass and come and join the rest of the parish in >> celebrating the eucharist as one community >> >> His emminence cardinal Simon Pimenta than called for a joint meeting of >> the ppc and it was decided to give a time of 2 yrs to the everardians to >> stop the mass and go to the church ,if you go through  the letter of 1995 >> guidelines given by the cardinal it clearly states this, but unfortunately >> Fr Blaise was transfered within six months and Fr ,Richard dsilva who is at >> present the parish priest was posted on the request of the  everardians ,the >> letter which was sent by the cardinal was not shown to any ppc member or >> parishoner but quitely hidden in the file ,and as matters got cooled down >> Fr, Richard along with some everardians went and met the cardinal in 1996 >> and gave him wrong information that the people of sion parish have no >> objection if everardians celebrate the sat mass , so the bishop gave them >> permission to celebrate mass on saturday . >> >> But the everardians took  advantage and first started daily mass,then the >> christmas midnight mass, the new year midnight mass, then lenten mission , >> so when the full parish gathers for important  ocassion the everardians are >> not a part of it even now when we are conducting the st anthony novenas you >> can hardly see any body  from everard >> >> This is thethe third time i have seen Fr, Richard being transfered to our >> parish on the demand of the everardians , i still cant understand why a >> priest who is 80 yrs old brought in as a parish priest when there are so >> many young and capable priest who can take the full parish together and make >> it a dynamic and active parish . >> >> kindly request Fr. Tony Dsouza our superior to send a young priest at the >> earliest ,or let the bombay archdioces take charge of this church before it >> becomes a battle ground for the parishoners >> >> >> >> Thanking you in christ >>

Franklin pereira >> >>

parihoner of olgc church sion >> >>

English: An image of Archbishop Oswald Gracious

English: An image of Archbishop Oswald Gracious (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

%d bloggers like this: