Responses: Deflated: “Ghar Wapasi” Balloon of RSS: Open Letter to Shri Mohan Bhagwat;

Dear Readers,

At the onset I wish to thank you all for tremendous response to the post, “Deflated: “Ghar Wapasi” Balloon of RSS: Open Letter to Shri Mohan Bhagwat;

The post has gone viral on internet with over 800 unknown people sharing it on their FACEBOOK page. I thank my colleague, Stanley Fernandes for mass circulation of the letter via E Mail. 

We have received number of calls and emails complimenting the efforts. Re posting herewith, some of the responses for the benefit of the readers of SILENT VOICE. The best one is the hand written note from a 90 years old Religious, Sr. Marie Rose from Nagpur, which I shall cherish for life. The same has been posted herewith.

I thank Fr. Austin Norris, Parish Priest of St. Anthony’s Church, Malwani for publishing it in Parish News Letter, TONIANTWEETS; through which Bishop Percival Fernandes learnt about it and sent his compliments.

Unfortunately, the EXAMINER, Newsweekly published by Bombay Archdiocese, has not published it, in spite of I personally handing it over to Archbishop Cardinal Oswald Gracias, with a request to do so. 

It was also mailed to SUVARTA/SHANTIDOOT, the Community News Letter published by Vasai Diocese.

Anyways, I thank, once again, all the readers of SILENT VOICE.




Silent Voice said,

February 8, 2015 at 9:43 pm · Edit

Via E Mail………

Mr. Pereira,
I salute you and thank you for this wonderful letter which you have written to Mr. Mohan Bhagwat.
You could not have expressed the facts and truths any better!
May our good Lord bless you and your family abundantly.

dmelloalex said,

February 7, 2015 at 4:35 pm · Edit

Why we Christians always think that our forefathers were converted from Hinduism to Christianity? When Christianity came to India in the first century AD nobody was talking about religion, our forefathers may not be the followers of any religion at that time. That’s why our past generations never been Hindus therefore, the issue of conversion of our earlier generations doesn’t arise at all and we need not be apologetic about it. We still assume that 80% of India is Hindu, it’s a myth. About 20-30% of the Indian population still do not follow any religion but RSS Parivar thinks that every one is Hindu. Religion doesn’t fill the empty stomachs. The brahminical forces just to want to keep on harping that this country is a Hindu Rashtra which is still a myth.

Hinduism is not a religion, it’s way of life with lot of rituals, caste systems. If not why the caste system is still prevalent in India? Dr Ambedkar was the first mass leader who got fed up with the Varna system and wanted to liberate people from Hinduism. One need to read and understand his childhood history to understand the boycott & difficulty faced by the backward classes during his time. The system has not changed much even today in spite of education & awareness. Hinduism also gives more importance to superstitions, those who oppose are either threatened or killed and sometimes forced to leave their settlements. Dr Perumal, UR Ananthamurthy and Dr Dabholkar are the examples of our recent memory.

Hinduism is a peace loving religion but Hindutva is a dangerous way of religion. All Hindus are not happy with Babri Masjid demolition, Ghar wapsi and threats in the name of religion. People want to live in peace, only 2% brahminical forces who are part of RSS want to keep the communal card burning. The new brahminical generations do not want to even join RSS as they do not subscribe to its ideology and therefore RSS is roping in the unemployed youth from OBCs by paying stipend and later regular salary as a pracharaks. For the youth of this country & their poor families it’s a matter of survival hence they mainly join RSS for a better life. Their parents are happy because they start earning at a very young college going days. These youth slowly become community leaders as they go through training and attain success within a short span. Since they are picked up at a very young age, by the age of 20 -22 they become full fledged pracharaks who start preaching against minorities. They think that all the ills faced by this country is only because of minorities

RSS and it’s parivar cannot survive without racking up issues every now & then. Their ideology killed the Father of the Nation and the trend still continue for those who oppose them. The cadres are given arm training, talking peace is new to them.They never respect Indian tri-colour but their own saffron flag. They never respected Gandhi but there is a history of hatred directed towards him and the same hatred killed him.

Ever since BJP came to power, the attacks on minorities have increased. The PM’s silence has emboldened the Parivar cadre to come out openly and create communal disturbance. Just to keep the tempo of disturbance RSS keep on raking the conversion bogey. Every one has a right to practice & propagate his own religion under the constitution. If anyone has any information about any conversion they are free to file a case but Hindutva forces do not want to follow the law of land but choose to intimidate the minorities. The missionaries have brought education, hope, dignity to the masses of this country and people opted for conversion looking at their good work. Only the community failed them to absorb into the mainstream because of the brahminical forces prevailing within the community. Only during the last 10-20 years things have started changing. Hope good sense prevail everywhere.

February 6, 2015 at 2:31 pm · Edit

why should then christians demand a term like Dalit christian and ask for reservation under SC/ST quota??? once you denounced the faith you belonged due to the unequal treatment .


  • Gauri Malur said,

    February 6, 2015 at 6:12 pm · Edit

    Dear Mr. Gupta,

    Would you like to read the whole article again?
    I offer my services to simplify this for you so you can understand it better.

    Silent Voice said,

    February 12, 2015 at 6:01 pm · Edit

    Via E Mail……..

    Your name shall be called John the Baptist & Daniel;

    Let’s continue to be BOLD & WISE & PASSIONATE about sharing the Gospel by all means, all the time all the way…
    We are encouraged, inspired & strengthened…

    Glory to God.

    Good job dear Dr. Greg.

    Kampu Thangzom, Guahati; Assam;

    Silent Voice said,

    February 11, 2015 at 5:45 pm · Edit

    Via SMS…..

    Dear Greg! I take my hat off 2 u and offer u sincere congratulations 4 the bold stand u took in writing to Shri Mohan Bhagwat. You are truly a prophet for our times! Letter is just too gd. Thnk you Greg , All of us r praying 4u.

    Sr. Lorraine.

    I spoke to the sender of this SMS. She is a Nun from Nagpur. She was happy to receive a call from me. What is important and I wish to share that with readers of SILENT VOICE. ” We have taken Hundreds of copies and distributed them all over Nagpur… They all have sent their Blessings to you and you will be remembered in our prayers, always”. She said.


    Silent Voice said,

    February 9, 2015 at 8:28 am · Edit

    From FACEBOOK…….

    Austin Norris: Well written Greg. Congrats n may they see the light. ..!!

    Silent Voice said,

    February 21, 2015 at 3:13 pm · Edit

    Via SMS…….

    Hello Greg; Hats off to you Greg for the letter sent to Mohan Bhagwat RSS. I am very much impressed and in full support of all that you are doing. Kind regards;

    Shirley Shetty, Nalla Sopara…

    Silent Voice said,

    February 18, 2015 at 2:05 pm · Edit

    Via E Mail……

    God bless this man for speaking out loud and on behalf of all Christians!
    > With kind regards,
    > Marian

    Silent Voice said,

    February 18, 2015 at 2:04 pm · Edit

    Via E Mail……

    Hi Greg,
    Thank you for writing the letter and forwarding it to the people that you
    did. I hope and pray that your letter will open some minds and hearts. If
    you do not mind, I wanted to know whether you received any response from any of them. I also wanted your permission if I could share your letter with my friends here in the USA and else where.

    I wish you well.
    Thanks & God’s blessings!
    Anslim Soares

    Silent Voice said,

    February 28, 2015 at 7:35 am · Edit

    Via E Mail……

    Dear Greg

    Congratulations on taking up the cause of minorities and Catholics in particular during very difficult times in your brilliant letter full of courage
    We in the UK have problems with ******* calling the indigenous population of Christians (infidels)
    Also the shooting of young Christian babies and crucifying teenage Christian males in Syria

    I would love to know if any of the individuals copied into this letter – reply to you and what they have to say

    May God be with you and yours

    Hazel Cardoza


    • Silent Voice said,

      February 28, 2015 at 7:37 am · Edit

      Thank you Hazel for your inspiring words. No, I have not received any response yet and I do not expect any. But would be pursuing the matter with President’s office. However, I wish to inform you, like you I have received acclamation from many of our brothers and Sisters.


      Silent Voice said,

      February 25, 2015 at 11:48 am · Edit

      Via E Mail…

      Dear Brother
      it was a very well written letter. if a person have even little sense of remorse would be a changed person. but, as bible said, its useless to throw Perls in front of the pigs. you should also sent him a copy written in hindi, i doubt he knows to read english.

      i wish more and more christian writers come forward and write such articles and publish them in various print and electronic media.
      keep in touch and god bless in your courageous works
      vikram anthony

      Silent Voice said,

      February 23, 2015 at 6:46 am · Edit

      Via E Mail………..

      Dear Mr. Gregory,
      Loving greetings to you.
      My hearty Congratulation to you for your wonderful letter to RSS leader.
      I do appreciate your love & concern to the Christian Community as well as to the Chatolic Church. Your letter had been highly Educative, very Informative, and very logical too. You have placed the Facts in a very Systematic and Sound manner. Thank you for your hard work. May God bless you abundantly. Take care. Love and kind wishes.
      Fr. Alex SDB. Gujarat.

      Silent Voice said,

      March 6, 2015 at 5:04 pm · Edit

      Via E Mail…

      Anthony Fernandes

      Well done Greg – for a holistic response.
      This needs wide, if not mass circulation – have made a small beginning
      God Bless……tony

      Silent Voice said,

      March 4, 2015 at 9:54 pm · Edit

      Via E Mail…

      Dear Mr. Pereira,

      Bravo and kudos to you. I must congratulate you on the letter to RSS chief. Trust the Lord will open their eyes to the truth. We now pray “Lord forgive them for they know not what they do”. They do need our prayers. They are but the Indian version of IS – fanatics and lack brotherhood. May the Lord forgive them. Thank you on all our behalf.
      God bless you.

      Bernie Pereira

      Achachan said,

      March 1, 2015 at 8:57 pm · Edit

      Yes, this is a wonderful letter with love and desire for clarity and not hatred.. If facts are sincerely studied and understood by all, none will follow these fundamentalist philosophy propagated by Bhagwat. It is really nice if people like Bhagwat has a dialogue with others.

      Silent Voice said,

      March 10, 2015 at 12:54 pm · Edit

      Via E Mail…….

      Dear Mr. Gregory,
      Loving greetings to you.
      I have sent you letter for nearly 217 people.
      Hope some thing good will come.

      Love and kind wishes.

      Silent Voice said,

      March 10, 2015 at 1:31 pm · Edit

      Via E Mail…..

      Message from Bishop Percival Fernandes…..

      ———- Forwarded message ———-
      From: Percival Fernandez
      Date: Mon, Mar 9, 2015 at 8:39 AM
      Subject: Appreciation

      My dear Fr. Austin,Going through your Toniantweets of March-April 2015, I found the “Onen Letter to
      Shri Mohan Bhagwat” by Greg R. Pereira just EXCELLENT !Please ask Greg to see that this, his Open Letter, reaches not only Bhagwat, but also the Prime Minister, and leaders of ALL POLITICAL PARTIES, and if possible to Chief Ministers of every State in India !With every good wish,


      Re: Fwd: Appreciation – Sent – Yahoo Mail India


      Thank you your Lordship for your encouraging words. The letter has been sent to Mr. Bhagwat, Hon. President,Hon. Vice President and Speaker in Rajya Sabha, Hon. Prime Minister and Leader of Opposition in Rajya Sabha, Mr. Ghulam Nabi Azad and Ms.Sumitra Mahajan, Speaker of Lok sabha by Speed post.

      It has been posted on internet on SILENT VOICE. It also has gone Viral via E mails.
      Following is the link to the post on internet…
      I have been receiving calls from as far as
      from Assam, Nagpur, Gujrat and beyond the borders from UK and USA…appreciating the letter.

      A religious from Nagpur called me to say that
      they have made hundreds of copies and have distributed in
      the vicinity of the place where the RSS HQ is situated..

      Hope the good counsel prevails
      and things would change for better..


      1. Silent Voice said,

        March 17, 2015 at 10:29 pm · Edit

        Via E Mail….

        Attachments9:26 PM (59 minutes ago)

        to emm—2012, M.O.M.

        We need faithful and strong Catholics like this gentleman, to defend the Catholic faith in all circumstances and not sucumb to appeasement. In the words of Jesus, ” Well done good and faithful servant! “.


      2. Silent Voice said,

        March 17, 2015 at 10:36 pm · Edit

        Via E Mail……

        Dear Greg
        A friend of mine the in U S of A sent me this open letter of yours.
        I want take this oportunity to say a big Thank you for being brave and bold to defend the Catholic Faith. It take a Strong Spiritual person have the guts a gift of the Holy Spirit to stand up to such persecution to the Catholic Faith.
        reading your letter gives me the courage and strength to continue to be firm in defending the Faith, all the teaching and the doctrins of the Catholic Church.
        God bless you always.
        Anthony Murray


      Via E Mail…

      Hello Mr. Pereira,

      I am Xavier Francis, originally from New Delhi. Now live in NY for 41 years. I am a medical professional, married with two grown up children and six grand children. Now I am retired but happily residing in NY with my wife, who belongs to Kerala. We both are, practicing Roman Catholics.

      I am writing to congratulate you for writing a very bold and open letter to some fool, who does not,

      even, know what is his religion. I am not a scholar but have a good knowledge of the believes people, like MB(RSS)) practices. I have had some discussion, while visiting small town in Himachal ( Solan ) near Shimla. The person is a professor in Chandigarh. He is Ph.D. He is an Indian. The topic was Hindu, Religion. He said, there is no religion as such called Hindu Dharm. Centuries ago; an Aryan tribe travelled to South-East from their native land. (Swastika) is the sign of their origin which is used in Germany

      They came down from Asia Minor which is considered to be the place somewhere south of Germany and close to some East European countries. They crossed over the mountains and entered a place called Sind which is on the western side of River Sindh ( now in Pakistan). These invaders named the inhabitants of Sind (Sindhi) as they travelled east and crossed over the Sindh river they landed on the Eastern ghat of Sindh River and they called that place Hind. They called people of that land Hindu. So everybody who lived in that place, they called them Hindu because they live in Hind. Now by fact we all know the people who live in the countries their origin, are identified by the name of the country they live in. No matter what their beliefs may be. All over the world and in every country people practice different religion for their convenience but they all are identified after the name of their native country. In India, no matter where we go, we all called Indian because we are born in India. Since India was called Hind by those invaders, we all are called Hindu. Every individual person born and live in Hind is called Hindu no matter which religion we belong to. Hindus, their religion does not have a name. Their religion is the religion of convenience, which is the culture and habit, which they follow for million years. It is what they are trying to impose on common men. Whatever you have written, about the constitutional rights of people, is true and we feel very proud of you. You have done an excellent job by writing very boldly and courageously.

      We wish, you had sent a copy of this letter to all the leading news papers in India. If you wish, I can find out the name and addresses of all the American papers so you can email them. Congratulations and I pray for you so these wolves do not run after you. They are brain less people.



%d bloggers like this: